Apostasy, the total rejection of christianity by a baptized person who, having at one time professed the christian faith, publicly rejects it. Introduction the ridda wars which was led by the first caliph abu bakr siddiq against the rebels in arabia is often misquoted, and not presented in their true historical context. Thats because islam teaches that apostates are to be killed. In islam, apostasy is sinful, but it would only be punished in the hereafter. Apostasy in islam is commonly defined as the conscious abandonment of islam by a muslim in. One useful effort comes from the apostasy and islam website, which is run by muslims. On the other hand, there are hadiths stating apostates were not sentenced to death. But this is only because the report has no real contextual information at all. Now, since quran is the only source of guidance for all muslims regardless of opinions or sects etc i wanted to know how the quran tackles this issue if.
Unlike apostasy, the crime of sabbe nabi, or swearing at the prophet, has been codified in the ipc. Quranic decrees on apostasy and is therefore unislamic, given. The reports of the prophets sayings and deeds are called ahadith. The translation of the meanings of sahih albukhari arabicenglish 9 volumes by muhammed ibn ismaiel albukhari author, muhammad muhsin khan translator, taqiuddin alhilali editor, nasif alubaydi editor, mahmud hamad nasr editor, muhammad amin almisri. Apostasy which is not aggravated by some other crime is not punishable in this world.
Islam, apostasy and the death penalty culturewatch. Islam and apostasy an interview with ibn warraq summary. Introduction the issue of apostasy irtidad and the punishment that islam has prescribed for an apostate is one of the least known and understood part of the shar ia islamic laws. After the concept of jihad, apostasy is most frequently cited by christian missionaries as a negative dimension of islam. In particular, the recent case in afghanistan has highlighted, once again, to many in the western world that the muslim world is neither civilized nor respective of human rights. If a muslim abandons islam irtidad heshe becomes an apostate murtad. Like the issues of stoning and hand chopping, apostasy in islam can only be. Apostasy in islam project gutenberg selfpublishing. One of the worlds most respected sunni scholars, yusuf alqaradawi, admitted in 2012 that if muslims had gotten rid of the apostasy punishment, islam wouldnt exist today. It lists muslim authorities from all eras of islamic history that oppose the death penalty for apostasy the. This is founded on the following quranic principles. Whoever believes that is an apostate and a disbeliever. Meaning shamail tirmizi, musnad ahmad all available english transalation as it comes from darussalaam, please do not mind but due to lack of a search engine it is not useful if one wants to find english of a particular hadith.
We know from historic islamic documents that during muhammads lifetime, and the lifetimes of the next four rightly guided caliphs, tens of thousands of. According to sharia law, an apostate must be killed because he is considered a rebel against the religion of islam. For muslims, apostasy the renunciation of ones religious faith is a sin punishable by death in many parts of the islamic world. The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in. Underlying principles there are four underlying islamic principles that are relevant to understanding the muslim position on apostasy. A source for acceptance of queer individuals into mainstream muslim society muhsin hendricks. No body is forthcoming to challenge this widely held belief as well as put forth a convincing argument about the. Islamic jurisprudence on apostasy is derived from the words of muhammad and the aforementioned actions of the caliph and other companions.
The issue of apostasy in islam yaqeen institute for. And these are not just some old religious squabbles which have no impact on folks today. Astonishingly enough, he was not apologizing for the beheading, torture, burning and murder of millions, but. Apostasy and the notion of religious freedom in islam core. Conceptualizing the hadith of the prophet muhammad.
The duty of any muslim is to convey the message and if somebody turns away, then the matter is between him and god. Laws criminalizing apostasy in selected jurisdictions library of. That is why, for islam to achieve 100% compliance to sharia enforcement, muslim individuals were told they must be allahs enforces of sharia on earth if. The notion that the crime of apostasy in islam was more a matter of protecting a state and social order than of policing individual beliefs was. Doctrinal differences, however grave, cannot be deemed to be apostasy. This report surveys the apostasy laws of twentythree countries in. After the concept of jihad, apostasy is most frequently cited by. In the classical legal texts, all surviving islamic schools. It is clear from the quran that there is no punishment for apostasy. Books on apostasy the following books discuss the problem of shariah laws requiring violence against people who leave islam, from a variety of perspectives. Muslims face a multitude of challenges, of which one is rejection. The body of evidence regarding apostasy includes the words and actions of the prophet aas as transmitted to us in relevant hadiths and traditions, attributed. We have not transliterated arabic words which have become part of english language, e. The four sunni schools of islamic law developed the consensus that male apostates must be put to death, and most also agreed that female apostates be dealt with in the same way.
One does not execute him immediately but repentance is offered to him. July 30, 2014 ihrdcs latest 50page report, apostasy in the islamic republic of iran, details the jurisprudential as well as the legal context in which apostasy cases are prosecuted in the islamic republic of iran. This is anchored by the belief that homosexuality is a major sin in islam and punishable by death under shariah. The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in islam 11 the context of this hadith was the occasion when the holy prophetsa ordered a census in medina. The punishment for apostasy lies in the hand of god almighty, against whom the offence has been committed. The sourcebooks of islam, however, are not so unambiguous.
All muslim scholars agree that sahih albukhari is the most authentic and reliable book after the book of allah, quran. The issue of apostasy in islam yaqeen institute for islamic. Apostasy is taken so seriously by muslims that it spawned the first of many major wars within islam immediately after muhammads death when several tribes wanted to leave islam and go back to their preferred religion. Hazrat mirza tahir ahmad, the truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in islam. Apostasy in the islamic republic of iran iran press watch. The islamic biblethe trilogy islam is defined by the words of allah in the koran, and the words and actions of mohammed, the sunna. Muslims are not keepers over those who go astray to coerce them to accept islam against their will. Punishment of apostasy as widely known islamic law it is widely known among the muslims and even the nonmuslims that the punishment for apostasy is mandatory fixed death penalty. Evidence of apostasy in islam, according to reliance of the traveller, a 14thcentury manual of the shafii school of jurisprudence fiqh. This text first explains the view about faith in god and whether or not islam can be forcefully imposed on others. An apostate is looked upon as worse than an infidel who has never professed faith in allah and mohammad as his prophet or in any way practiced islam.
Islam bashers have time and again tried to carry the point by pointing out that islam orders the killing of a person if he or she reverts to another religion from islam. The sunna is found in two collections of textsthe sira mohammeds life and the hadith. Critics of islam often accused islam of lacking the freedom of religion due to the shariah for those who decide to leave islam known as apostasy law in the west. This is confirmed by the words and deeds of muhammad. Thoughts on apostasy in islam from a series of discussions on new issues in islamic theology apostasy and freedom written by mahdi azizan for the imam assadiq research institute headed by his eminence, ayatullah shaykh mirza jafar subhani translated by saleem bhimji for alfath almubin publications and the islamic publishing house. Islam treats apostasy as a crime to be punished by death. The current hype1 much has been said in recent months concerning the law of apostasy in islam. The official penalty for committing apostasy in islam is death by beheading. Yet one of the muslim worlds greatest authorities, the. However, as hadith traditions of the prophet muhammad is considered the second most important source for islam, an argument could be made that if hadith strongly supports the death penalty for apostasy, then this penalty should apply today. Islam promises heavenly rewards to individual muslims who take the law into their own hands. He also stated that he does not know of any country which is ruled by 100% islamic law.
No, just leaving islam wont get you death penalty, but after leaving islam, but in some countries,if you go against islam and try to drag more people out of islam by false information and propaganda,then. People are dying right now for the sin of apostasy just as they have been for the past 1400 years. It is distinguished from heresy, which is limited to the rejection of one or more christian doctrines by one who maintains an overall adherence to jesus. I will address the socalled apostasy hadith firstly islam allows for the freedom of religion, therefore, is someone apostatizes they are not going against freedom of religion and are protected. Jonathan brown yaqeen institute by eric bin kisam on july 6, 2017 0. The conflict between human rights and apostasy in islam 7 in terms of the hadith, they argue that the hadith of the prophet muhammad does not hold the same rank as the quran.
As all these facts are vague, so reliance on an ambiguous hadith which is merely based on the inference of a companion in such an important issue and to pass judgment contrary to the manifest verses of the holy quran is extremely unjust. The definition of apostasy from islam, and whether. No hadith can overrule a principle outlined in the quran. Introduction to translation of sahih muslim in the name of allah, the most compassionate, the most merciful sahih muslim is a collection of sayings and deeds of prophet muhammad pbuh also known as the sunnah. Muslim lived a couple of centuries after the prophets death. Where available, weve included a link to purchase the book online, and you might look in your local library for them as well. On the question of apostasy in islamwhether a born or converted muslim has the right to abandon islam for another or no religionthe radical position is well known. Apostasy in islam understanding islam and christian. Apostasy in the islamic republic of iran iran human rights. The truth about the alleged punishment for apostasy in islam xi the name of muhammadsa, the holy prophet of islam, has been followed by the symbol sa, which is an abbreviation for the salutation sallallahu alaihi wasallam may peace and blessings of allah be upon him. Apostasy apostasy is the abandonment of a religion.
It includes the act of converting to another religion or nonacceptance of faith to be irreligious, by a person who was born in a muslim family or who had previously accepted islam. The line between moderate and radical muslim continues to fade. Common hadith booksall volumes in one pdf engarabic. The topic of death penalty for apostasy defection form ones religion in islam seems to be a controversial one since many people have both positive and negative answers regarding the issue. Anyone who swears at or commits qazf against the great prophet of islam peace be upon him or any of the great prophets, shall be considered as sab ulnabi a person who swears at the prophet, and shall be sentenced to the death penalty. Since, a census, by its very nature, is a broad ranging entity, the most broadranging definition by him was given in the context of that particular occasion. Others argue that the death penalty is an inappropriate punishment, inconsistent with the quranic injunctions such as quran 88. Mahdi, quran, hijra, ramadan, hadith, ulema, umma, sunna. Apostasy and a false hadith may 31, 2017 beyond24 leave a comment go to comments it is very unfortunate that there are many muslims and predominantly muslim countries who actually think that they have a moral mandate to put to death anyone who leaves islam. Pdf there are various verses from alquran that speak about freedom of beliefs. Therefore, where there is a contradiction between the quran and a hadith, it is the hadith which is.
This is just one of the many very real differences between christianity and islam. The punishment for apostasy from islam is a controversial topic for muslims living in the west and for exmuslims everywhere. The only freedom of belief in islam is the freedom to become muslim. If rejecting one of the pillars of islam is considered to be a crime warranting war against such people, it is only logical for the prescribed punishment for apostasy in islam to be death. The second main piece of hadith evidence for the apostasy ruling leaves a similar impression. Assalaam alaikum, azak allah khair for all the good work. The quran remains in exactly the perfect form as it was revealed to muhammad sa, whereas the ahadith were collected decades and sometimes centuries later.
Those who turn their back on islam are to be executed. Former muslims united a shiite opinion on apostasy. The notion that the crime of apostasy in islam was more a matter of protecting a state and social order than of policing individual beliefs was articulated in the 1940s by the south asian muslim activist intellectual abul ala mawdudi d. The quran is the primary scripture in islam, while the ahadith are supplementary. We discuss apostasy with ibn warraq, critic of islamic fundamentalism and author of a recent book leaving islam. However, none of them instruct the believers to exercise. Apostasy in islam international institute of islamic thought.
In islam, a muslim is not allowed to leave and embrace other religions. Apostasy does islam allow freedom of religion or does it threaten the death penalty for apostasy. Next, the discussion on the issue of apostasy and its two categories. Jul 05, 2017 the only hadith evidence that does not include a specific political dimension for the crime of apostasy is the discussion between the companions abu musa alash. I wish you could include more hadith in your search engine. Apostasy in the islamic republic of iran iran human. It includes the act of converting to another religion or rejection of faith to be irreligious, by a person who was born in a muslim family or who had previously accepted islam. Apostasy means, to renounce the religion or a religious principle after accepting it. Sharia states that the killers of apostates and adulterers are not to be punished as murderers. Sahih albukhari in arabicenglish all volumes 19 the. In islam, apostasy is a flagrant sin and guilt for which certain punishments have been specified in fiqh islamic law. An apostate in islam is a muslim who rejects islam after being either born into it or after embracing it as a convert from some other religion. Abdullah saeed and hassan saeed freedom of religion, apostasy and islam,ashgate publishing, march 30, 2004,isbn.
1486 1641 85 313 961 295 1633 1098 1438 875 1294 230 197 670 202 1396 1446 714 297 1470 1457 1238 957 1555 1271 687 180 413 794 624 1280 532 4